Thursday, January 04, 2007

MCP's Top 10 Films of 2006: #7 & 6

Finally got around to continuing the list....

7. Brick

This is what I love about digital filmmaking. Technology is finally getting cheap enough that we’re starting to get some truly original films that would not have the opportunity to exist otherwise. Brick, for instance, was made for $300,000 and was cut using off the shelf software. Five years ago that would have been impossible. How cool is that?
But that’s not why this movie made my list. It made the list because it was a great story that was fresh and original. I would have never thought of combining High School & Film Noir, but once you think about it, it makes perfect sense. They’re both built around arch-types. In high school you’ve got Jock’s, Drama kids, Druggies, etc. Noir is no different. You’ve got your hero, the damsel in distress, the snitch, the dangerous woman, etc. Combining them gives you this weird hyper-reality. Do high school kids talk like this? No. But the dialogue doesn’t sound awkward either. The context of it all makes it work.
And who the hell knew that the kid from “Third Rock from the Sun” could act? He was amazing! He managed to take all that dialogue and make it flow naturally. The guys who played the Brain and the Pin were also particularly noteworthy. The one other performance I simply have to mention was Nora Zehetner, who plays Eden on “Heroes”. She really pulled off the “woman you’re not sure you trust” role perfectly. You knew she was bad news, but you couldn’t help but want her on screen
Best indie movie of the year. Period.
Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 78%

6. The Fountain

If I had to pick just one movie on this list that Goose should NEVER see, it’s this one.
I remember walking out of this flick with a very solid opinion of what it this movie meant. What I found fascinating was that the 3 people I saw it with had come to 3 different conclusions. Unlike most American cinema, this film does not give you answers. You have to actually think and work to your own conclusions.
Don’t get me wrong. It’s not like this film is dense & abstract to the point where it’s not enjoyable. In fact, I found it to be a very emotional story, and what I took away from it was actually a simple story about love and loss.
Hugh Jackman & Rachel Weisz pretty much carry this movie by themselves as supporting characters are really minor, at best. Through each of the three stories (Story A: 500 years in the past. Story B: Today. Story C: 500 Years in the future) we are truly centered on these two lovers facing, and trying to cheat death in order to be together. Jackman in particular really impressed me in this film. Ever since he came onto the scene, my first thought whenever I see him is “Wolverine!” But like just about all of his performances, he manages to impress me by giving a performance where you forget about all that and just become invested in his current character. If only this guy could pick his projects better (Van Helsing, Kate & Leopold), he really has what it takes to be a major player in Hollywood.
The real kudos in this movie go to Director Darren Arnofsky & Cinematographer Matthew Libatique (Both did “PI”, “Requiem for a Dream”). This movie is nothing short of beautiful. I could watch this movie with the sound off and still be riveted. I saw this film months ago, yet I can still vibrantly remember so many shots in this film. Most of what I remember are relatively simple shots too. This is a film that I could spend hours just analyzing the composition of each frame. In fact, that was probably my favorite thing to watch for. When film makers tell stories that use overlapping characters in multiple times, they’ll use various tricks to help the audience figure out which time period we’re currently in. The most common thing I’ve noticed is the use of different color palettes (The episode of Firefly called “Out Of Gas” is a perfect example). What I thought was interesting was that this film used shapes. In Story A it was Triangles, Story B was squares and Story C was circles. I was completely fascinated by this, and when I saw it for the second time I made a point to look for it.
At the end of the day this is a 50/50 kind of movie. You’re either going to love it, or you’re going to hate it. I haven’t really encountered too many people who were somewhere in the middle.
Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 50%

34 Comments:

Blogger Unknown said...

Casey, I think I lost interest in your Top 10 movies of the year lists about 2 weeks ago... can we make the last one a Top 5? Com'n son! You can write 5,000 words on the crappy movies that came out this year but can't put together a post on the forever promised but will never be completed ComiCon post? That's crazy talk.

Thu Jan 04, 11:26:00 AM PST  
Blogger Casey said...

I really hate you Joe.

Thu Jan 04, 11:37:00 AM PST  
Blogger Jimbo said...

I like the reviews...I don't understand what the rush is...I think I commented on my mutual love for "Brick" earlier...I'm almost to the point where I need to see it again to appreciate the brillance...

Afronsky is difficult and I go cautiously into "The Fountain", on one hand I loved "Pi", on the other "Requiem for a Dream" I actually shut off half-way through...I tend to think that this film will be somewhere in between, but I'll give it a go anyway

Thu Jan 04, 11:49:00 AM PST  
Blogger Casey said...

Yeah, Arnofsky is tough...I LOVED Requiem for a Dream. I thought it was absolutely brilliant.

BUT...I will never ever watch it again. If was just too damn depressing. I remember I had to watch 2 hours worth of cartoons just to get myself out of the funk that movie put me in. But I'm a firm believer that if you ever want to keep kids from doing drugs, you show them this movie.

Thu Jan 04, 11:59:00 AM PST  
Blogger Goose said...

Why do you have to say "Goose should never see this movie"

Im a David lynch fan. He is the king of movies that require post movie conclusions and a dip into the puma box for clarity

Just because I didnt like Serenity dont insult my movie prowness. I was watching sci fi and fantasy when you were just an itch in your daddies pants, plus I have more sci fi in my blood then you ever will.

so get off your high horse Serenity Boy before I bitch slap you back to your meaningless reality called "Your life"

Goose, stepping down off his high horse

Thu Jan 04, 12:05:00 PM PST  
Blogger Casey said...

Lets point out a few things:

1. This is coming from a man who has "You Me & Dupree", "Click" and the crappy "Wicker Man" Remake in his Netflix queue

2. Saying "I have more sci fi in my blood then you ever will" is total Bulls**t. I mean, c'mon. I'm not gloating, but lets just be real about this.

3. The one real film conversation we had was about Nightwatch, where you cited the following reasons for not liking the movie:
- It had subtitles (if that's not a sign of film retardation, I don't know what is)
- It had an in-joke that you didn't get (Goose not get why puny audience laugh. Goose Smash!)
- It was hard to follow.

4. You've also earned yourself a reputation with me for dogging non-big studio flicks that I like, which is fine. You are entitled to your opinion. But the fountain is exactly the kind of film that you've shown in the past to have a distaste for.

5. And for the record: Your movie prowess is s**t.
Snoochie Boochies

Thu Jan 04, 12:25:00 PM PST  
Blogger Jimbo said...

ouch...tough room...agreed on "Just Say No to Drugs-Requiem Style"...someone get the Drug Czar on the phone right now...and I didn't shut it off because it was a bad movie, hell I sat the "The Hulk"...I just couldn't watch anymore...sanity was more important to me....

Thu Jan 04, 12:27:00 PM PST  
Blogger Jimbo said...

I smell a civil war approaching...

Thu Jan 04, 12:29:00 PM PST  
Blogger Casey said...

I know...at this point I'm practically asking for an "MCP has never kissed a girl" retort.

Anyone that could sit through the Hulk gets my sympathy. I don't know what the hell Ang Lee was smoking when he thought of an Incredible Hulk movie and thought "oooo...art film!" If one marvel character deserved just a crazy action film, it was the Hulk.

Thu Jan 04, 12:36:00 PM PST  
Blogger Unknown said...

"Itch in your daddies pants"... that line slayed me. And although I like the comeback, Casey... Goose indeed does have the pedigree to lay the smack down on your Joss Whedon Fan Club ass. (Although the "Out Of Gas" reference was nice... but Soderbergh's "Traffic" would be a better example)

Thu Jan 04, 12:38:00 PM PST  
Blogger Goose said...

Ok....you want to go toe to toe little man than so be it

1. This is coming from a man who has "You Me & Dupree", "Click" and the crappy "Wicker Man" Remake in his Netflix queue

Serioully Casey. I have 3 people in my life. and since you have decided to go through my netflix queue did you know that I cancelled netflix, cleared out my queue and just started reloading it just after Xmas. You'll learn in life that when you have a family you learn to make comprimises. Thats not a shot on your single status. That is just a fact. I dont have time to watch movies on my own. They are normally films that either the family would like, or that the wife will enjoy and will watch together.

2. Saying "I have more sci fi in my blood then you ever will" is total Bulls**t. I mean, c'mon. I'm not gloating, but lets just be real about this.

Casey. Your view of the SciFi world (By your reviews and proclaimed loves) focuses around the last 4-5 year of movies and television. There is 50 years of SciFi that I have watched and loved. Books that I have read. You are the posterboy of the graphic novel child.

3. The one real film conversation we had was about Nightwatch, where you cited the following reasons for not liking the movie:
- It had subtitles (if that's not a sign of film retardation, I don't know what is).
First of all, I dont mind subtitles in certain types of movies. I didnt like the Subtitles it that type of movie. Dont use a tewrm like retardation when you are generalizing off one conversation. It make you look ignorant.
- It had an in-joke that you didn't get (Goose not get why puny audience laugh. Goose Smash!)
This goes back to the same argument when I saw sin city, Serenity and Nightwatch. Not that they are bad movies, but they require you to have the backstory before watching, or else there are things that you miss. This again proves your ignorance as a Graphic novel baby
- It was hard to follow.
And your point is......?

4. You've also earned yourself a reputation with me for dogging non-big studio flicks that I like, which is fine. You are entitled to your opinion. But the fountain is exactly the kind of film that you've shown in the past to have a distaste for.

Go back and look over some of your posts and Find where I bash any of your movies. I dont. And do you know why. we rarely see the same films. You'll actually notice I rarely even comment at all in your movie posts.


Basically Casey I see you a a Ignorant Uncultured Prick. You are the product of a generation that has a limited scope of understanding when it comes to movies. You watch some independent films. Make some movies that show up on youtube and generally see yourself as a misunderstood genius filmmaker who's talents are undiscovered.

Basically you are a movie snob. There.
I give you a generous serving of my famous F&*k you sandwich. Bon Appetit

Thu Jan 04, 02:15:00 PM PST  
Blogger Train said...

Watching this must be just like what it was like to watch Fort Sumter get fired on!!!

Thu Jan 04, 02:26:00 PM PST  
Blogger Goose said...

Glad you can sit back and enjoy it....I hope watching it doesnt cause you any Blog Retardation. I'd hate to see that happen

Thu Jan 04, 02:41:00 PM PST  
Blogger Jimbo said...

simply amazing...never thought I'd see Goose and MCP battle it out for #1 Sci-Fi Geek privilages...I always thought we would reserve that for a special slow-week in July for Duke and MCP...oh well...

Here's a point for both sides to think of:

*Goose, I think your pedigree alone (Planet of the Apes, Twilight Zone, etc...)nominates you along with favorites like Flash Gordon and original Star Trek...which earns you major old skool Connery-eque Bond points

*MCP, while I think your taste in Sci-Fi is a little lame, I have to be honest that the comic encyclopedia that you carry around in your head is ridiculous and just the pure volume of ridiculous films you see earns you somewhere between "Man with a Golden Gun" Roger Moore cool and old Connery Diamonds are Forever...

Thu Jan 04, 03:18:00 PM PST  
Blogger Goose said...

I dont want the title. It is MCP's prized trophy. I just hate be discarded in a conversation because someone thinks they know all about me.

Goose is like an Onion. Not only does Goose have many layers, but he smells if you leave him out too long, and is the building block of Good Food.

Thu Jan 04, 03:33:00 PM PST  
Blogger Casey said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

Thu Jan 04, 04:16:00 PM PST  
Blogger Casey said...

1. I don't have netflix, Train hooked my up w/your list per my request. So I didn't notice, and I don't care.

"You'll learn in life that when you have a family you learn to make comprimises."

Get off your f'n pedestal. I hate that holier than thou s**t

2. I'm still going to call complete bulls**t on my supposed lake of sci-fi knowledge. Do I know sci fi from the last 10-15 years better than the last 30? Yeah. That was the age I grew up. Does that mean that I don't know older sci-fi really well? Hell no!

I find this point actually a little funny, because it clearly means you don't jack s**t about me. If you said something like that in front of my friends they would burst out laughing.

And don't f**king talk down to me like I don't read books. That's bulls**t. Again if you knew the first thing about me you'd feel like an idiot. Just because I've never written a post about my favorite Heinlein novels, or why I can't stand Assimov's writing doesn't mean I don't where I speak.

I keep sci-fi discussions in the lodge to the recent because it has a better chance of being discussed.

Hell I wrote a college paper about Richard Matheson's novel "I Am Legend" and it's subsequent film adaptations.

I'm sorry that I'm not related to anyone famous. But that does not buy you street cred

And don't give me this "Graphic Novel Baby" bulls**t. All it does is show off how truly far your head is up your enormous @$$. It's that kind of mentality towards a medium that you clearly don't understand that just pisses me off.

3. Just a quick side about "In-Jokes" in movies.
First. You're a moronabout the Nightwatch joke. All that joke was, was a kid in a VAMPIRE movie, watching Buffy the VAMPIRE slayer. THAT'S THE JOKE! It's not rocket science. You just have to be aware that there was a popular TV show called Buffy.

Secondly, most in jokes have nothing to do with the plot. Sin City for example: There is not a single in joke in the whole film that contributes to the plot in any way. You don't have to have looked at a single page of the sin city comic to understand the film. Just because the audience chuckled at Frank Millers cameo and you didn't get it has nothing to do with understanding the movie.

As for subtitles...I'm not even going to touch that one. Except to say that if you want an accurate translation of what is being said in the film than you have to learn to live with them. Just deal with it and move on. Whining will accomplish nothing.

"Basically Casey I see you a a Ignorant Uncultured Prick."
Right back at you Goose

"You are the product of a generation that has a limited scope of understanding when it comes to movies."
And I'd say that you're an old man intent on going off about "when I was your age"

"You watch some independent films. Make some movies that show up on youtube and generally see yourself as a misunderstood genius filmmaker who's talents are undiscovered."
Wow...you hit that one on the head. That's exactly how I see myself. I'm SO misunderstood. That's exactly what I do. I go home every night and watch "Clerks" on repeat muttering how that'll be me one day!

Oh yeah, and go f**k yourself.

Thu Jan 04, 04:32:00 PM PST  
Blogger Casey said...

And for the record...all I did was point out that I didn't think you'd like a movie. You're the one who had to turn into a whiny little beotch.

Thu Jan 04, 04:34:00 PM PST  
Blogger Jimbo said...

I bet this will get us a few more hits

Thu Jan 04, 05:07:00 PM PST  
Blogger Casey said...

I love it. You constantly berate & belittle me all the time on this f**king blog and 90% of the time I just f**king ignore it. I mean hell...my life could be worse. I could be you.

I say something like "Here's a movie Goose should never see" and you do your typical "Jayne's a douche" banter to which I actually respond to for once with "Goose is a douche" banter.

Then you had to go and take it to 11. Now we both look like asses

But whatever...I don't even care. Go get back on your pedestal and f**k yourself.

San Andemas High School Football Rules!!!

Thu Jan 04, 09:26:00 PM PST  
Blogger Goose said...

Casey.
Here is my extended Olive Branch

You really pissed me off with some of the things that were said and continued to pour fuel on the fire whick got me even more pissed. Lets agree that neither of us need to comment or talk about eachother for a while. We have nothing more to say.

I apologize to you and I am moving forward.

Fri Jan 05, 12:00:00 PM PST  
Blogger Unknown said...

Odds that Casey will show up to the next Lodge event -- Saturday Night Texas Hold 'Em (after the Seahawks game) -- 10-1.

Fri Jan 05, 12:08:00 PM PST  
Blogger Goose said...

Dont be an ass Joe. I am apologizing to Casey and hopefully this is over. He should be welcome at a Lodge Event.

Fri Jan 05, 12:13:00 PM PST  
Blogger Train said...

I asked MCP to come over with me after the game. Goose stepping up with the Olive Branch shows that the lodge does now the meaning of the word PALS...

This must have been what it was like to watch Grant and Lee meet at Appomattox Court House

Fri Jan 05, 12:36:00 PM PST  
Blogger Goose said...

There has been no acceptance. The War my continue. Boundries may be drawn

Fri Jan 05, 12:55:00 PM PST  
Blogger Casey said...

Sorry for the delay, work has been busy busy.

I accept your apology Goose.

And I myself apologize for continuing to escalate the situation.

Fri Jan 05, 01:06:00 PM PST  
Blogger Unknown said...

I'm completely serious about those odds, not trying to be an ass... Casey just never shows.

And Train, keep up the historical references on your comments. Seriously, I love them. Classic Lovato.

Fri Jan 05, 01:27:00 PM PST  
Blogger Goose said...

I feel like the end of an ABC after school special, although Im thinking of starting in on Train for sharing what is in my Netflix queue. That is how you get removed as a Netflix friend.

Train. I will deal with you tomorrow

Fri Jan 05, 01:28:00 PM PST  
Blogger Train said...

And this must have been what it was like when Hitler stopped his planned invasion of England and attacked Russia is the summer of 1941

Fri Jan 05, 01:45:00 PM PST  
Blogger Casey said...

Only 3 things have kept me from lodge events:

1. Prior engagements
2. Fifa
3. Hangovers

Fri Jan 05, 02:02:00 PM PST  
Blogger Unknown said...

Don't forget World Of Warcraft, midnight readings at Zanadu, blow-up dolls, Firefly chatrooms, the Cartoon Network & jerking off.

Fri Jan 05, 02:50:00 PM PST  
Blogger Train said...

Joe said Jerk!!

Fri Jan 05, 03:08:00 PM PST  
Blogger Casey said...

You're right...I did forget something:

1. Prior engagements
2. Fifa
3. Hangovers
4. Joe 2.0

Fri Jan 05, 03:14:00 PM PST  
Blogger Goose said...

I have no comment

Fri Jan 05, 06:08:00 PM PST  

Post a Comment

<< Home