Monday, February 27, 2006

Wonderlic This!

Does Vince Young have the brain to play QB in the NFL? I'd love to get our resident Football coaches' (Goose, Train & Jimbo) opinions on the Wonderlic test. Word is that Vince Young bombed his Wonderlic test. Rumor had Young scoring a 6 on the test. To me, bottomline is that Vince Young is a phenomenal athlete who has a funky arm slot and throwing motion -- but nonetheless is a true leader. And probably more improtant, a winner.

For those who don't have Insider, apparently the results of his first test haven't been confirmed -- and combine officials have said the score of 6 was wrong -- plus, ESPN.com's John Clayton reported that Young scored a 16 on his second try (something his agent also confirmed) and Young is expected to take it a third time (maybe he's never heard Yoda's "try" speech before). According to the article, the results of that test will not be released to NFL teams until next week, so it remains completely speculation at this point.


"The combine officials assured us that score (6) was false and that the accurate score will be known when the combine results are given to each team," Young's agent, Major Adams, said.

Scouts Inc. is reporting that the highest Wonderlic score registered at last year's scouting combine was a 40 (QB Alex Smith) and the lowest score was a 6 (RB Frank Gore). Scouts Inc. was also told by an NFL scout that the other two top quarterbacks this year fared much better on this test, with USC's Matt Leinart scoring a 35 (at the combine) and Vanderbilt's Jay Cutler scoring a 29 (in a test given prior to the combine). So the question is this -- if you were an NFL GM on the clock -- would you take Young over Leinart or Cutler?

4 Comments:

Blogger seatownshawn said...

Man, this is tough territory. Athletic ability is one thing, but the mental capacity of a quarterback cannot be under-emphasized. I'm trying to find out what Ryan Leaf did on the aptitude test, but can't seem to find anything. I'm not sure when they instituted the Wonderlic....

Leaf comes to mind because the guy had all the physical talent in the world....and we all know what happened there.

Young is used to sitting in the pocket and using his feet to make a play when the defense is taking away everything else. If Vinny doesn't have the ability to read a cover-2 and react WITHOUT just making a run for it, then he will die a slow NFL death....just like Ron Mexico.

Electrifying athletes are fun to watch at the QB position....but they don't win Super Bowls. It will only be a matter of time before Vince Young takes a hit that he can't handle...and it's all downhill from there.

Mon Feb 27, 01:47:00 PM PST  
Blogger Train said...

I agree with your comments Sean. I also love the Ron Mexico reference.

Mon Feb 27, 01:57:00 PM PST  
Blogger Unknown said...

Apparently Michael Vick scored a 20 on his Wonderlic test. And if you follow the last link on my post, you'll see a short list of scores from former pros.

Young does remind me of a Randall Cunningham (and no, not because he's black), due to their lanky frames and weird throwing motions. Tremenous athlete. Small brain.

Mon Feb 27, 02:05:00 PM PST  
Blogger Jimbo said...

I like the O-Tack score on the highest and J. George was a 10, also how Akili Smith cheated...I'm not sure why they are allowed to take the test over though?

Mon Feb 27, 03:18:00 PM PST  

Post a Comment

<< Home